AccountingQA Latest Questions

Aadil
AadilCurious
In: >

A. True B. False

  2. prashant06 B.com, CMA pursuing
    This answer was edited.

    The answer is B. False. Before jumping on the solution to know why goodwill is not fictitious, we need to know what are fictitious assets? Fictitious assets are false assets or not true assets. These are not assets but expenses & losses that are not written off from the profit & loss accountRead more

    The answer is B. False. Before jumping on the solution to know why goodwill is not fictitious, we need to know what are fictitious assets?

    Fictitious assets are false assets or not true assets. These are not assets but expenses & losses that are not written off from the profit & loss account but shown in the balance sheet as assets under the head miscellaneous expenditure. For example preliminary expenses, loss on issue of debentures, etc.

    Goodwill is not a fictitious asset but an intangible asset which means it has no actual physical appearance and cannot be touched and felt like other assets like buildings and machinery. It is nothing but a firm’s reputation which can be sold just like other assets help the business grow and earn revenue. Goodwill is shown in the balance sheet as follows:

    See less
    • 0
Karan
Karan
In: >

  2. Pooja_Parikh Aspiring Chartered Accountant

    No, Goodwill cannot be called a fictitious asset. A fictitious asset does not have any physical existence or realizable value. Although it is recorded in the assets column, it is not really an asset, rather it is an expense that is incurred during the accounting period. Its benefit, however, is realRead more

    No, Goodwill cannot be called a fictitious asset.

    A fictitious asset does not have any physical existence or realizable value. Although it is recorded in the assets column, it is not really an asset, rather it is an expense that is incurred during the accounting period. Its benefit, however, is realized for extended periods. This is why they are recorded as assets. They are recorded in a single year and are amortized over the years. A fictitious asset is neither tangible nor intangible.

    Examples of Fictitious Assets

    • Preliminary expenses
    • Promotional expenses
    • Discount on issue of shares/debentures etc.

    Now, goodwill is an intangible asset that relates to the purchase of a company. It is the amount that a company pays over the net worth of the company being purchased. This can be because of its brand value, good customer base, etc. As a company’s reputation improves, its goodwill increases accordingly. Therefore, It does not have a tangible existence but it does have a monetary value. They are also recorded on the asset side of the balance sheet under the head “Intangible assets”.

    Reason for not being a fictitious asset

    Since goodwill is an asset and not an expense, it cannot be called a fictitious asset. Moreover, goodwill has a realizable value. Unlike fictitious assets, goodwill can be purchased or sold. Therefore, goodwill is termed as an intangible asset but not a fictitious asset. The major difference between an intangible asset and a fictitious asset is:

    See less
    • 0
Bonnie
BonnieCurious
In: >

  2. AishwaryaMunot

    Before we jump in the concept of valuation of Goodwill, let us first understand the meaning of term “Goodwill”. Goodwill is an Intangible asset of the business. As the definition of Intangible asset, Goodwill cannot be seen or felt. In simple words it is business’s worth or its reputation earned oveRead more

    Before we jump in the concept of valuation of Goodwill, let us first understand the meaning of term “Goodwill”.

    Goodwill is an Intangible asset of the business. As the definition of Intangible asset, Goodwill cannot be seen or felt. In simple words it is business’s worth or its reputation earned over a period of time.

    Calculation of value of the goodwill in monetary terms is done at the time of merger or acquisition of the business. Goodwill is often applied to businesses which are earning large number of profits, have crucial corporate links and large customer/client base.

    Self-earned goodwill is never shown in monetary terms in business’s own balance sheet while goodwill which is purchased is shown in the asset side of the balance sheet of the buyer business.

    Following are the methods under which goodwill can be valued:

    1. Average Profit Method – In this method, Goodwill is calculated by average profits multiplied by the number of years purchased. Typically, last 5-6 years profit figures are taken ignoring any abnormal gains or loss during the year. Formula for the same would be as follows:

               Goodwill = Average Profit x No. of Years Purchase

    1. Weighted Average Method – This method is updated method of average profit method, Profits of the previous years are calculated by specific number of weights. This method is useful when there is a lot of fluctuations in the profits and importance has to be given to current year’s profit. Formula for the same would be as follows:

              Goodwill = Weighted Average Profit x No. of Years Purchase

    Where,

    Weighted Average Profit = Sum of Profits multiplied by weights / Sum of Weights

    1. Super Profit Method – Super profit is additional profit generated by the business over normal profit. Further for the calculation, Super profit is capitalized by the normal rate of return and resulting figure is value of Goodwill.

    Formula for the same would be as follows:

             Goodwill = Super Profits x (100/Normal Rate of Return)

    1. Annuity Method – In this method, Discounted amount of the super profits is calculated by taking into consideration the current value of the annuity at rate of return.

    Formula for the same would be as follows:

             Goodwill = Super Profit x Discounting Factor

    1. Capitalization Method – In this method, existing capital employed is deducted from capitalized number of average profits or super profits. The resulting figure is Goodwill.

    Formula for the same would be as follows:

               a. Average Profit Capitalization Method –

                 Goodwill = [Average Profit / Normal Rate of Return x 100] – Capital                                                        Employed

               b. Super Profit Capitalization Method –

                Goodwill = Super Profits x (100/ Normal Rate of Return)

    See less
    • 0
Atreya
AtreyaCurious
In: >

  2. Ishika Pandey Curious ca aspirant

    Definition Goodwill is an intangible asset that places an enterprise in an advantageous position due to which the enterprise is able to earn higher profits without extra effort. For example, if the enterprise has rendered good services to its customers, it will be satisfied with the quality of its sRead more

    Definition

    Goodwill is an intangible asset that places an enterprise in an advantageous position due to which the enterprise is able to earn higher profits without extra effort.

    For example, if the enterprise has rendered good services to its customers, it will be satisfied with the quality of its services, which will bring them back to the enterprise.

    Features

    The value of goodwill is a subjective assessment of the valuer.
    • It helps in earning higher profits.
    • It is an intangible asset.
    • It is an attractive force that brings in customers to the business.
    • It has realizable value when the business is sold out.

    Need for goodwill valuation

    The need for the valuation of goodwill arises in the following circumstances :
    • When there is a change in profit sharing ratio.
    • When a new partner is admitted.
    • When partner retires or dies.
    • When a partnership firm is sold as a going concern.
    • When two or more firms amalgamate.

    Classification of goodwill

    Goodwill is classified into two categories:
    • Purchased goodwill
    • Self-generated goodwill

    Purchased goodwill :

    Is that goodwill acquired by the firm for consideration whether paid or kind?
    For example: when a business is purchased and purchase consideration is more than the value of net assets the difference amount is the value of purchase goodwill.

    Self-generated goodwill

    It is that goodwill that is not purchased for consideration but is earned by the management’s efforts.
    It is an internally generated goodwill that arises from a number of factors ( such as favorable location, efficient management, good quality of products, etc ) that a running business possesses due to which it is able to earn higher profits.

    Methods of valuation

    1. Average profit method
    2. Super profit method
    3. Capitalization method

    Average profit method: goodwill under the average profit method can be calculated either by :
    • Simple average profit method or
    • Weighted average profit method

     

    See less
    • 0
A_Team
A_Team
In: >

  2. Kajal
    This answer was edited.

    Yes, Goodwill is a fixed asset because it adds to the value of the business over a long period. Goodwill can never be calculated for a short period.   GOODWILL Basically, goodwill is a premium or you can say an additional price you are paying because of the reputation of a firm or a person. YouRead more

    Yes, Goodwill is a fixed asset because it adds to the value of the business over a long period. Goodwill can never be calculated for a short period.

     

    GOODWILL

    Basically, goodwill is a premium or you can say an additional price you are paying because of the reputation of a firm or a person.

    You may have seen some famous shop in your locality which usually charges a higher price as compared to the other local shops selling the same product.

    You may have also noticed that bigger brands like Bata, Titan, Zara, etc. charge higher prices for their products as compared to the same products available in the local market and people are even willing to pay for them. Ever wondered why?

    This is because of the goodwill created by them over the years by providing quality products and services, good employee relationships, a strong customer base, social service, a brand name and so on. Customers trust them and for this trust, they are even willing to pay higher prices.

    Goodwill is the quantitative value (i.e. in monetary terms) of the reputation of the firm in the market.

     

    FIXED ASSETS

    An asset is any possession or property of the business that enables the firm to get cash or any benefit in the future.

    Fixed Assets are assets which are purchased for long-term use. They are for continued use in the business for producing goods or services and are not meant for resale. For example- Plant, machinery, building, goodwill, patents etc.

    Fixed assets can be tangible or intangible.

    Tangible assets are those assets which can be seen and touched and have physical existence like Plant and machinery, building, stock, furniture etc.

    Intangible assets are those assets which cannot be seen or touched i.e. they don’t have any physical existence like goodwill, patent, trademark, prepaid expenses etc. Even though they can’t be seen or touched by they have value and are not fictitious assets.

     

    Goodwill as a Fixed Asset

    Goodwill is an intangible asset as it cannot be seen or touched but has value and adds value to the business over a long period. Thus, goodwill is a fixed asset.

    It is shown in the balance sheet as a Fixed asset under the head Intangible asset.

    Goodwill can be

    • Self-generated (Non-Purchased goodwill)
    • Purchased goodwill

    Self-generated goodwill is created over a period due to the good reputation of the business. It is the difference between the value of the firm and the fair value of the net tangible assets of the firm.

    Goodwill = Value of the firm – Fair value of net tangible assets

    Here, F.V of net tangible assets = Fair value of tangible assets- Fair value of tangible liabilities

    Purchased goodwill arises when one business purchases another business. It is the difference between the price paid for the purchased firm and the sum of the fair market value of the assets received and liabilities to be paid by them on behalf of the purchased firm.

    Goodwill = Purchase price – (F.V of assets received + F.V of liabilities to be paid)

    Only purchased goodwill is recorded in the books of accounts because it is difficult to correctly calculate the value of self-generated goodwill as the future is uncertain, also its valuation depends on the judgement of the person calculating it, which defers from person to person. Since there is no fixed standard to calculate self-generated goodwill only purchased goodwill is recorded as the price paid for it at the time of acquiring another business.

    Suppose Firm A acquired Firm B.

    Purchase price= $100,000

    Assets received=$60,000

    Liabilities (to be paid by Firm A on behalf of Firm B) = $10,000

    Goodwill = $100,000 – ($60,000 + $10,000) = $30,000

    This, goodwill of $30,000 will be recorded under the head Fixed Asset, subhead Intangible Assets in the balance sheet of Firm A (that is in the balance sheet of the acquiring firm)

    See less
    • 0
Aadil
AadilCurious
In: >

  2. Mehak
    This answer was edited.

    To understand why we do not record self-generated goodwill in accounting, let us first understand what goodwill is and its accounting treatment. What is Goodwill? Goodwill is an intangible asset of a business.  It represents the reputation and brand value of a business built over time. It is a valueRead more

    To understand why we do not record self-generated goodwill in accounting, let us first understand what goodwill is and its accounting treatment.

    What is Goodwill?

    Goodwill is an intangible asset of a business.  It represents the reputation and brand value of a business built over time. It is a value over and above the tangible assets of the business.

    Goodwill often arises when a business purchases another business and pays a premium, which means a price higher than the fair value of the business.

    Characteristics of Goodwill

    Goodwill has the following characteristics:

    1. It is an Intangible asset, meaning it has no physical existence and cannot be seen or touched.
    2. It is generally recognized during transactions in mergers and acquisitions.
    3. It is the value attributed to the brand value and reputation of the business.
    4. It adds value to a business beyond its tangible assets.

    Example of Goodwill

    Let us take an example to understand the concept of goodwill better.

    Suppose there is a company ABC Ltd. It is planning to acquire XYZ Ltd. The fair value of the assets of XYZ is calculated to be 600,000. However, ABC has agreed to pay a sum of 650,000 to acquire the company. This difference of 50,000 is goodwill.

    Impact on Financial Statements

    Goodwill is shown under the assets side of the Balance Sheet.

    What is self-generated goodwill?

    Self-generated goodwill in simple words means the positive reputation or trust that a business earns over time through their own hard work and decisions. It’s not something bought or inherited but something built from scratch internally, like a brand’s reputation, loyal customers, strong relationships, or unique ideas.

    For example, a small business that goes the extra mile to offer great customer service or always delivers high-quality products over the years will naturally build goodwill.

    It is also known as internally generated goodwill.

    Why do we not record sef-generated goodwill?

    Self-generated goodwill is not recorded in the financial statements because of the following reasons:

    1. Measurement may not be reliable: The measurement of self-generated goodwill is majorly based on the judgment of the managers. It is based on the value creation because of a good reputation or consumer base of the business, which might not be measured accurately.
    2. Conservatism principle: As per the conservatism principle, a business shall not overstate its assets or liabilities. However, self-generated goodwill might be overstated.
    3. Lack of market transaction: There is a lack of a market transaction that ensures verification of the value of goodwill as in the case of purchased goodwill.
    4. Manipulation: There are higher chances of manipulation of financial statements through self-generated goodwill.

    Conclusion

    On a concluding note, self-generated goodwill is something that adds real value to a business, but it’s not something that can easily be measured or captured in financial statements. Accounting is all about providing clear, reliable information, and including goodwill would make things murky and open to manipulation. Even though it doesn’t show up on the books, you can still see its effects in a company’s reputation and success. Maybe in the future, businesses will find a way to highlight it better, but for now, leaving it out helps keep financial reports honest and straightforward.

    See less
    • 0

Most Helping Users

Astha

Astha

Leader
Simerpreet

Simerpreet

Helpful
AbhishekBatabyal

AbhishekBatabyal

Helpful